Cat Litter Substitutes – 10 Things You May Have Never Considered

More common than you might think, many people opt for alternatives to retail cat litter and find their own substitutes. Some pet owners want to stop purchasing cat litter as a result of allergies. Other cat owners have environmental concerns. We’ve researched the topic to bring you 10 interesting ideas.

Cat Litter Substitutes – 10 Things You May Have Never ConsideredHere are 10 cat litter substitutes you may never have considered – 

  1. Newspaper
  2. Horse bedding pellets
  3. Chicken feed
  4. Wood pellets
  5. Wood shavings
  6. Alfalfa pellets
  7. Whole Wheat
  8. Sand
  9. Toilet train
  10. Artificial Turf

Whether you’re tired of litter particles kicked all over the floor or you’re frustrated with the cost of commercial cat litter becoming excessive.  Whatever your reason, you may want to keep reading and see how these alternatives fare. And yes, it’s perfectly ok to stick to commercial cat litter – just as long as you know what your options are.

Is a cat litter substitute the right choice for you and your cat?

The pros might outweigh the cons for the cat litter substitute of your choosing, depending on the method you use.  Some things to consider are:

Cost

For many pet owners, reduced price leads the list of pros. Depending on the substitute you choose, you might notice a significant drop in cat litter fees, especially if you own more than one cat.

Convenience

Depending on where you live, how accessible materials are, and how big your storage area, you might find it more convenient to utilize a do-it-yourself cat litter alternative. You can make kitty litter in bulk and keep it handy for future use rather than make frequent trips to the store.

Health

Many commercial cat litters in stores treat their formulas with chemicals. Some of these chemicals can cause health problems for your pet. Gastrointestinal issues can occur if your cat ingests sodium bentonite clay, an ingredient used in many clumping cat litters.

Some cats develop respiratory problems from the silica dust in many kitty litters. Even humans may experience an allergic reaction from the dust.

And then, there’s the issue of your own health. Read more here: Is Cat Litter Harmful to Humans?

Environment

You may be unaware of the environmental impacts caused because of some cat litters on the market. Sodium bentonite clay obtained via an environmentally harmful strip-mining process can lead to contaminated water supplies and destroyed agricultural land and forests. It’s important to choose a sustainable cat litter, whether purchased or handmade.

Furthermore, some cat litters are safer to dispose of than others. Some cat litters require disposal via landfill while other kitty litters are compostable.

Cat Litter Substitutes

By now you’ve probably realized that you can make your cats litter at home. Some cat litter methods are more complex than others. Depending on what materials you have available and how much time you want to invest in making your cats litter, there are a wide variety of options for you to choose. Keep reading for a list of 10 cat litter substitutes you may have never considered.

Homemade Cat Litter

1. Newspaper

This cat litter is made using shredded paper, dish soap, and baking soda. You can make this kitty litter substitute in roughly 30-45 minutes.  Here’s how you can make it:

  1. Shred a generous amount of newspaper into small strips and fill the cat litter tray.
  2. Soak the shredded newspaper in warm water with dish soap until the water becomes gray and it is an oatmeal consistency.
  3. Drain the water. Add clean water to soak the paper again (do not add soap). Drain again.
  4. You might want gloves for this step! Sprinkle baking soda liberally and knead the wet paper, squeezing out the moisture.
  5. Spread the paper out over a screen to dry. It should be a crumbly texture.
  6. When completely dry it’s ready for use.

Pros: Newspaper and junk mail are readily available which makes this a handy and economical option for many pet owners.

Cons: If you do not soak the newspaper or junk mail long enough you may notice ink on your cat’s paws.  Others don’t like the mess involved in preparation. Luckily, ready-made options are available for purchase, such as Purina Yesterday’s News Unscented Paper Cat Litter.

2. Horse bedding pellets

An unusual choice, equine bedding pellets are a great alternative to cat litter. Easy to make, mix the pellets with baking soda and a bit of water. They are usually available for purchase online and some specialty pet stores.

Pros: Made from sawdust, these pellets absorb well, and are affordable.

Cons: The pellets will swell up when wet, then disintegrate into sawdust, therefore tracking outside of the box or overflow can occur. Be careful not to overfill the litter box.

3. Chicken feed

 

Chicken Feed | Photo by Mr ATM

This alternative is so easy to make, mix chicken feed with baking soda for odor control. When using chicken feed as a cat litter replacement, ensure the feed has a crumbly texture and is free from chemicals and additives.

Pros: Chicken feed is a safe and affordable substitute for cat litter.

Cons: Since chicken feed is corn-based, it can become moldy and make your cat sick if they ingest it. Some pet owners may find this alternative inconvenient as it can attract rodents, you shouldn’t purchase it in bulk, and should only use fresh feed.

Ready-to-use Alternatives

4. Wood pellets

Hardwood and softwood pellets, designed for burning in wood stoves, are generally easy to come by. If you purchase wood pellets from hardware stores, ensure no additives are used, such as accelerants.

If you’re concerned about chemicals, you can even buy wood pellets specifically designed for cat litter use. A favorite brand among many cat owners is Feline Pine, a sustainable and chemical-free alternative.

Pros: Wood pellets have excellent odor control, some smelling of pine or cedar depending on the type of pellets you choose. They also provide superior absorption, disintegrate quickly, and create minimal dust.

Cons: Oils from the wood are toxic to your pet, such as pine and cedar oils. Be sure the pellets used indicate the oils are removed during the kiln-drying process. If you’re unsure either way, contact the manufacturer if you have any questions or the store where the pellets are purchased.

5. Wood shavings

Wood shavings and sawdust are great for absorption and, especially if you have a woodworking shop, are easily obtained. If you plan to use shavings and sawdust, use untreated wood that is chemical-free.

Pros: Both economical and biodegradable, you can compost this kitty litter in your non-edible garden.

Cons: You may notice dust and tracking of shavings outside of the litter box and wood shavings do not clump as well as commercial cat litters.

6. Alfalfa pellets

Many pet owners commonly use Alfalfa pellets as rabbit food. These pellets absorb well and eliminate odor.

Pros: An eco-friendly option, alfalfa pellets are biodegradable.

Cons: If you overfill the cat litter pan with alfalfa pellets, you may notice increased dust and tracking.

7. Whole Wheat

Whole wheat berries can ground into a coarse powder (or a smooth consistency if your cat prefers) and spread in your cat litter box. You can also mix in oats, depending on texture preference.

Pros: An environmentally friendly option, this cat litter option is compostable in a non-edible garden.

Cons: This kitty litter alternative does little to mask pet odors due to urine. sWheat Scoop offers an all-natural wheat cat litter which also provides odor control.

8. Sand

If you’ve known anyone with a sandbox for their children, you’ve likely heard them lament that their cat loves to use it as their litter box. Sand is easily obtained, purchased in bulk, and most times easily stored since it can be kept covered outside.

Pros: Sand doesn’t hold pet odors and clumps well.

Cons: Unfortunately sand is easily tracked outside of the litter box. You may notice decreased tracking by using a cat litter mat.

Uncommon Methods

9. Toilet train

You read that correctly. It’s possible to toilet train your cat!

“Wally on [the] toilet seat” | Photo by Rosiesugrue
A word of warning before we describe the method. This may not be a good fit for any cat. Never force your cat to become toilet trained. If Kitty doesn’t appreciate the idea, let it go and stick to litter boxes.

Some cats find the idea of climbing on the slippery toilet bowl too abhorrent. Even if you manage to teach them, odds are down the road they’ll decide your rug or bed make better bathrooms. In other words, proceed at your own risk – or skip to the next item.

With plenty of treats, patience, and a plan, you can teach your crafty kitty cat to share your bathroom facilities. You may even be able to show your cat how to flush the toilet!

If you choose to teach your cat this method:

    1. Place the litter box next to the toilet they’ll use. With this in mind, when you need to move a litter box it’s important to do so gradually.  Don’t rush your cat and move the litter box to the bathroom gradually. Sudden changes may upset your cat.
  1. Place a cat training seat on top of the litter box. Allow your cat to adjust to using the seat on top of the litter box.
  2. Bit by bit, raise the litter box to the height of the toilet.
  3. When your cat is efficiently using the cat training seat on top of the litter box, consider that your sign. It’s time to move the seat on top of the toilet seat.
  4. If your cat is hesitating or seems nervous, don’t force them. Gently pet your cat to encourage bathroom use. Give your cat treats after using the litter/bathroom.
  5. Allow your cat roughly three weeks to adjust to this process.

There are also kits available to help facilitate this process, such as Kitty’s Loo Cat Toilet Training Kit/Seat. Many cat owners say this popular product not only helped them train their cat to use the bathroom, but the company offers superb customer service as well.

Pros: Almost zero clean-up required not including the time you will spend cleaning up any unforeseen (but expected) accidents that may occur.

Cons: If you plan on toilet training your feline, we recommend doing so when they’re young. It is difficult to teach an older cat who has become accustomed to a litter box and will likely be stubborn and set in their ways.

10. Artificial Turf

It might surprise you to find artificial turf, commonly found on sports fields, on this list. It’s an acceptable cat litter substitute as well as a sports green! Not only is it aesthetically pleasing but it’s easy to maintain. You can either purchase a roll of artificial grass, cut and place it into your cat litter box, or buy a ready-made mat as an alternative.

Pros: Depending on the quality you choose; artificial turf is resilient and easy to clean. Depending on the product, you can shake the excrement into the trash and rinse the artificial grass with a hose.

Cons: Some cats may disapprove of artificial grass since they are unable to scratch and hide their feces, therefore, they may destroy the turf in an attempt to do so.

Again, use with caution and never just switch from a proper litter box to this. Try offering this alternative in addition to your existing box and see if that works.

Materials to avoid as cat litter substitutes

We do not recommend using potting soil as a cat litter substitute in your home. Potting soil is incredibly messy and is easily tracked outside of the litter box. It does not clump well, and soil holds pet odor.

If you’re using any kind of wood shavings – make sure they’re pet-safe AND cat-safe. Some types of wood and plant matter can be toxic for cats.

How to transition to a litter substitute

Changes are stressful for most cats, no matter big or small. It’s essential to make any changes gradual and subtle. If you’d like to try transitioning to a cat litter substitute, you have two options.

Your first option is to mix one part of the substitute with three parts of their current cat litter. Over five days, you can gradually increase the ratio of cat litter substitute.

Another option is to place a second litter box next to their current litter box. Fill the second litter box with the cat litter alternative. Allow your cat time to explore both litter boxes. This option is handy if your cat is already displaying behaviors that indicate they don’t like their current litter. If you notice your cat relieving themselves outside of the litter box or using their current litter box as quickly as they can, they may be ready for a change.

Whichever cat litter or cat litter substitute you choose, be sure to make the change slowly. A sudden change in routine or environment is upsetting for most cats. Do your pet a favor and consider their preferences before making any changes to their litter box. Besides, for some cats, it’s more than just about a bathroom but a sense of security as well.

Have you tried any of the substitutes described here? What did you think? Or maybe you can share a new idea that we haven’t listed? Leave a comment and let us know.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *